Most homes in America use furnaces for heat. They work, they're reliable, and contractors know how to fix them.
Your house's cold air gets pulled into the furnace, warmed up inside, then blown back through your ducts. Gas and oil models heat air with a heat exchanger. Electric ones use heating coils. Your thermostat runs the show, turning everything on when it gets cold and off when you hit your set temperature.
Best for:
Pros:
Cons:
Price range: $2,800-$6,500 installed
Best for:
Pros:
Cons:
Price range: $2,200-$5,000 installed
Best for:
Pros:
Cons:
Price range: $3,500-$7,500 installed
Best for:
Pros:
Cons:
Price range: $3,200-$6,800 installed
AFUE numbers tell the real story about your heating bills. This rating shows what percentage of your fuel money goes toward heating your house versus getting wasted up the chimney. A 90% AFUE furnace turns 90 cents of every fuel dollar into heat for your home. Skip anything below 85% AFUE; it's throwing money away. For cold climates, go 90%+ or don't bother upgrading.
Basic motors work like old light switches – full blast or nothing. Variable-speed motors adjust power output to match what your home actually needs. They run longer cycles at gentler speeds, which gives you steadier temperatures and cleaner air. Buy variable-speed if your budget allows. Your electric bills can drop $200-$300 annually.
Standard steel heat exchangers get the job done and keep costs reasonable. Stainless steel lasts longer and handles temperature swings better, making it worth the extra money when you're planning to stay in your home for many years. Working with manufacturers taught me that stainless steel heat exchangers withstand thermal cycling much better than regular steel. Test data shows they last 20+ years in normal conditions. Aluminized steel offers middle-ground pricing and durability. Don't waste money on fancy coatings; they're marketing fluff.
Basic furnaces (80% efficiency) use your existing chimney and hot exhaust gases. High-efficiency models (90%+ efficiency) cool exhaust gases so much that they require plastic pipes going through your wall. I've seen installations where homeowners wanted high-efficiency but couldn't use it because their furnace room had no exterior wall access. This affects installation costs and where you place the furnace.
Working in the HVAC industry showed me reliability data with fewer Carrier warranty claims than other brands in the $4,000-$6,000 range. This is my top pick for most homeowners.
Popular models:
Known for:
Best fit: People who want reliability and easy service access
My work with manufacturers showed me Trane heat exchangers fail less than almost any other brand. Yes, you pay more upfront, but their units last forever.
Popular models:
Known for:
Best fit: People staying in their homes long-term who want something bulletproof
Lennox furnaces are known for reliability, efficiency, and good value. They last long and lead the market in smart features.
Popular models:
Known for:
Best fit: People focused on efficiency and quiet operation
Contractors prefer Rheem because parts are readily available and the units are straightforward to work on.
Popular models:
Known for:
Best fit: Budget-minded homeowners who want reliable heating without premium prices
Goodman is basic but reliable. Skip the premium models, stick with their entry-level units.
Popular models:
Known for:
Best fit: First-time buyers or rental property owners who want functional heating at low upfront cost
Don't even think about installing a furnace yourself. I've read too many stories about DIY gas connections that leaked carbon monoxide; people have died from this mistake. Even electric units need heavy-duty wiring that starts fires when done incorrectly. Local codes in most areas demand permits and inspections too.
Help your installer by clearing the area and making sure they get easy access to the furnace location.
Here's what every proper installation needs:
Efficiency ratings hit your wallet hard every month. An 80% efficient furnace wastes 1 out of every 5 dollars you spend on fuel. A 95% efficient model only wastes 5 cents per dollar.
Gas beats electric for heating costs almost everywhere. But your insulation, ducts, and thermostat habits matter just as much. I've talked to people whose leaky houses barely saved money from high-efficiency furnaces until they sealed air gaps and added insulation.
Here's real cost breakdowns for Midwest homes in the middle of winter:
What you pay depends on utility rates, how well your house holds heat, and usage habits.
Includes cleaning the heat exchanger, checking gas connections and pressure, testing safety controls, lubricating the blower motor, inspecting electrical connections, and measuring performance.
Companies charge $100-$200 for this work. Skip it and you'll pay way more when something breaks in January.
Signs: No heat, cold air, or nothing at all
Try these first:
Call someone when: Basic fixes don't work, you smell gas, or electrical parts look damaged
Signs: Big temperature differences between rooms, uneven heating
Try these first:
Call someone when: Problems stick around after basic fixes – could be ductwork sizing or blower issues
I've read about cases where return ducts collapse in crawl spaces, causing exactly these symptoms.
Signs: Banging, rattling, squealing, or grinding when the furnace runs
Try these first:
Call someone when: Grinding, squealing, or loud banging continues – these point to failing blower motors or heat exchanger problems
What furnaces actually cost:
Contractors mess this up all the time. They wing it or use rules from 1985. Oversized furnaces turn on and off constantly, waste fuel, and heat rooms unevenly. Undersized units run nonstop but never quite keep up when it gets really cold.
Contractors must use Manual J calculations to determine the correct size, measured in BTUs per hour. Homes generally need 30-60 BTUs per square foot, though drafty older homes demand more while well-insulated newer construction needs less.
Don't let anyone guess at sizing , I've heard of too many problems from contractors who eyeball estimates instead of doing proper calculations.
As you're getting quotes for a new furnace, ask each HVAC company these questions:
Here's four ways to cut your heating costs that actually work:
Please reach to us if you cannot find an answer to your question.
15-20 years with regular maintenance is normal. Quality units sometimes hit 25 years. Gas models last longer than electric because they have fewer moving parts. Test data shows some units running fine past 20 years.
Equipment parts get covered 5-10 years, heat exchangers 20 years to lifetime. Installation work gets covered 1-2 years around here. Look into extended service plans if you want more coverage.
Thermostats, filters, and zone controls can be upgraded on existing systems. But efficiency improvements like variable-speed blowers mean replacing the whole unit. There's no way around it, I've seen the engineering behind retrofit attempts and they never work right.
Too-big units cycle on and off constantly, create uneven temps, and make the air muggy. Too-small ones run nonstop but never get your house to the right temperature, especially when it's really cold.
Big furnaces that short-cycle die young, sometimes 8-10 years.
Some utilities give back $300-$1,500 for high-efficiency furnaces. Federal tax credits apply to 95%+ efficiency models. States have their own programs too. Areas with energy choice get the best deals.
Replace when your furnace hits 15 years and needs repairs costing more than half of replacement cost. Same if it keeps breaking down, bills keep rising, or you can't find parts. I've heard from homeowners whose older furnaces needed $1,800+ repairs, replacement made more sense financially.
Your furnace connects to other systems:
Ready to find the right furnace for your house? Smart HVAC USA connects you with local HVAC pros who'll figure out exactly what you need and give you recommendations that fit both your home and your wallet.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.